« Welcome Back (again) Recidivists | Main | Sunday Sunday Sunday »

But it's a good kind of tired. . .

Sunday - prep.

Monday - trial day, 37 cases, all KNP/CTS except for 2.  State tries to get us to go on (arguably) our weakest case.  Really really tries.  I mean like really really really tries to the point that they accuse us of underhandedly manipulating the trial order to avoid this case.  We start to pick a jury but the panel is struck (on motion of the court, although the prosecutor's final question would have been grounds to strike as well.)

Tuesday - regular calendar day - the usual grind.  We pick on that weak case the state was absolutely gunning for.  ("There's no way they can win this case - it's *soo* good for us.")  We get a jury, and go with myself, the Lioness and Baby Bull.  (The Mayor's on a much deserved vacation with his family.)

And we win.  Jury's out for 25min before returning a Not Guilty.  It was a good "hell yeah" moment. 

Our regular prosecutor was backed up by 3 other state attorneys, while we had 2 other PDs helping us out.  So it was kind of a scrum.  Actually it was a drag out, eye gouging, sand kicking fight - surprise last minute statements, suppression motions, discovery violations, motions in limine, cops getting colorful on the stand, and our usual dozens upon dozens of objections during the state's direct (resulting in a few guts-for-garters stares and one denigrating-the-defense comment at state's close, resulting in the court reserving ruling on a motion for mistrial.)

I think my favorite moment came when the state was making a somewhat incomprehensible argument and started citing different statutes and rules of criminal procedure but got the numbers confused.  I got to stand and in a puzzled voice say something like - "But that's a motion to suppress - surely the state can suppress its own evidence without the need for a motion."  (I forget what the actual statute was - it was something about that absurd though.)  Another precious moment courtesy the state and my tax dollars.  Actually my favorite moment would have been the judge and I exclaiming in near stereo (she's faster than me) "That's non-responsive" as an officer tried to weasel in some just-excluded observation of their own on an unrelated question.

So although it was my kind of fight, I'm now dog tired as the trial adrenaline begins to ebb.  We started picking a jury at 2:30 and finished the trial at 9:30.  Given that we started at 8:30 and got a fifteen minute lunch beak, that's a damn long day in the courtroom.

And tomorrow, as usual, is a trial day.  Up and at 'em.

(BTW - I'm not selectively blogging about only the victories as one e-mailer suggested.  Sometimes we don't go to trial on trial day, for any number of reasons.  We've only had a handful of defeats (knock wood!) and they're all recorded here.  Not all of our victories are though.)

Comments

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

About Me

My Book

  • Ice Sculpture of Mermaid with Cigar

    Icecoversmall Is now available at Amazon

    You can also read about it

Legal Disclaimer

  • First off, I’m not your lawyer. This is a strictly personal weblog which muses both on legal issues and my personal experiences. Writing to me does not make me your lawyer. Asking questions of me does not make me your lawyer. Any writings in this blog (or any links from it) are simply not legal advice, either generally, or in reference to anyone’s specific circumstances. Do not rely on anything you read here as a definitive statement of the law or as legal advice. Laws vary from place to place. If you have legal questions or require legal advice, contact a local lawyer, or better, several lawyers. All comments here reflect the changing views (such as they are) of the author, not my employer or any other person or party.